Home / Research / The Second Hearing
Research · Musicology · Aesthetics · Musical cognition
The Second Hearing
Nikolai Medtner, Sergei Rachmaninoff, and the Limits of Retrospective Musical Understanding
Developmental scholarly reading edition · Not peer reviewed · Proposed listener effects are untested; additional source examination remains outstanding.
Start here
Can hearing a melody again change what it meant the first time?
Rachmaninoff and Nikolai Medtner both built remarkable works around melodies that recur and change. We sometimes describe Rachmaninoff as the emotional composer and Medtner as the intellectual one, but that distinction undervalues both.
This chapter asks a more specific question: when a theme returns after other music has unfolded, can it change our understanding of what we heard earlier? Musical scores can show how composers arrange that possibility. They cannot, on their own, prove what listeners experience.
Through Medtner’s Sonata-Reminiscenza, the larger Forgotten Melodies cycle, and comparisons with Rachmaninoff, Brahms, Schubert, and Liszt, the study distinguishes remembering a melody from reinterpreting it. It examines what previous scholars established and what additional listening research would need to show.
The question: Can music change our understanding of its own past?
A mapped reading experience
Explore the chapter
The concluding sections describe objections, an unexecuted research protocol, and the critical sources. Skip to references.
Academic abstract
This chapter examines whether Nikolai Medtner’s compositional handling of thematic return creates a distinguishable form of retrospective musical understanding. The originality problem is unusually severe: Schmalfeldt (2011) theorized formal becoming; Gheorghieva (2020), Predvechnova (2021), Miranda (2016), Rizzi (2021), Shin (2018) and Tarasova (2023) already address Medtner’s memory, temporal organization, semantic imagery or cyclic form; and Beller-McKenna (2021) shows how thematic recollection can transform expressive understanding in Brahms. The chapter therefore does not claim that Medtner invented recollection, retrospective form, or the meaningful return of earlier music. It defines retrospective status revision (RSR) more narrowly as a context-dependent change in a hearer’s interpretation of a previously encountered musical event, beyond recognition, formal relabeling or familiarity. The revised argument examines the 1922 Zimmermann first edition of Forgotten Melodies I, later editorial variants, the historical restructuring of the cycle, and documented thematic relationships in Sonata-Reminiscenza; it sets those procedures against measure-specific Rachmaninoff examples and negative comparators in Brahms, Schubert and Liszt. An original comparative schematic maps the relationships without presenting them as evidence of an actual psychological outcome. A detailed proposed listening protocol distinguishes the possible formal affordance from an empirically established listener effect. The result is a constrained theoretical research contribution and a source-critical hypothesis, not a demonstrated composer-level psychological difference or a claim of doctoral completion.
Keywords: Medtner; Rachmaninoff; Sonata-Reminiscenza; Forgotten Melodies; musical time; retrospective interpretation; cyclic form; musical cognition; music aesthetics.
01The problem: what could count as Medtner’s distinctive achievement?
An account of Nikolai Medtner’s genius becomes unconvincing as soon as it depends upon a depreciated Sergei Rachmaninoff. The familiar division between Rachmaninoff’s melodic immediacy and Medtner’s intellectual construction is rhetorically satisfying but musically weak. Both composers write melodies capable of arresting a listener in the moment, and both organize large forms through motivic economy, transformation, and recurrence. Their documented friendship and reciprocal dedications complicate any attempt to cast them as antagonists. A useful comparison must establish a difference of compositional operation or listening consequence, rather than assigning one composer feeling and the other thought.
Medtner’s historical position has nevertheless posed a genuine explanatory problem. He maintained a commitment to tonal and thematic principles at a moment when much musical historiography came to privilege rupture: new harmonic syntax, new timbres, new conceptions of rhythm, and explicit challenges to inherited forms. Yet a composer can retain the vocabulary of a tradition while changing the temporal conditions under which that vocabulary becomes intelligible. The issue is not whether Medtner was secretly a more advanced modernist than Scriabin, or whether formal conservatism should be renamed innovation. It is whether the processes enacted within his inherited language merit categories that conventional stylistic narratives underemphasize.
My answer is a research proposition, not a superlative. In certain works Medtner appears to create an asymmetry between the identity of an idea when first presented and its standing after later relationships become audible. The opening can seem sufficient; the work subsequently makes its sufficiency revisable. A familiar theme can be restored within a recapitulation while the recapitulation itself introduces material that was not available to memory. A final cycle-piece can recall an opening idea under changed tonal and accompanimental conditions, making recognition and altered significance occur together. These are verifiable compositional circumstances. Whether they produce a distinct form of understanding in listeners remains to be demonstrated.
The argument is therefore divided into three evidentiary levels. The first is textual: what the published scores and documented revisions make available. The second is analytical: how the relationship of passages can reasonably be construed. The third is perceptual: whether listeners actually revise earlier interpretations because of later material. Nothing at the first level automatically proves the third. The chapter deliberately resists the common slide from compositional ingenuity to speculative psychology.
02The prior-art problem: remembrance, form, narrative
A credible novelty claim must begin with the work most likely to defeat it. Maria Gheorghieva’s “Organisation of Musical Time in Sonata-Reminiscenza by N. Medtner” (2020) explicitly argues that the sonata’s arrangement of musical time resembles the act of recollection. Her account identifies the double exposition, the return of the introductory theme, and the appearance of contrasting new material in the recapitulation. Its abstract already makes a claim close to the thesis of the earlier version of this chapter: unusual formal procedures are related to the processes of remembering. To repeat that claim in more philosophical prose would not constitute an original dissertation contribution.
Gheorghieva is not the sole obstacle. Haeshin Shin’s 2018 Boston University dissertation reconstructs the sources, changing versions, musical analysis, and performance practice of Forgotten Melodies I, Op. 38. Drawing on documentary and editorial evidence, Shin shows that the first cycle was not a fixed eight-component object from the outset. Its 1921 Moscow programme lists six entries, but a closing Alla Coda is attached to the preceding Canzona in the manuscript and is consequently sometimes counted within a five-item early version. In 1922 the expanded cycle contained eight musical components, although the first-edition title page still designated the last as a coda rather than as a numbered ‘No. 8.’ Shin’s account of Medtner’s annotations and thematic relationships supplies a historical and technical foundation; its findings must be credited to her rather than attributed to this chapter.
Nicolò Rizzi’s “Memory and Oblivion: Narrative Traces in Medtner’s Forgotten Motives” (2021) directly occupies the domain of remembrance and musical narrative. Tatyana Shevchenko’s contribution to the same volume addresses the performative interpretation of Sonata-Reminiscenza. The existence and scope of these studies are established bibliographically; their complete arguments have not all been independently inspected for this revision. A dissertation cannot legitimately announce priority over them without obtaining and reading their full texts. Nor should it pretend that the absence of a freely accessible full text is evidence of an unoccupied field.
Other work considerably limits claims about Medtner’s philosophical uniqueness. Wendelin Bitzan’s The Sonata as an Ageless Principle (PhD dissertation, 2018; revised open-access edition, 2019) situates Medtner’s sonatas within form history and analyzes his departures from familiar sonata procedures. Oliver Markson (2017) explores form and narrative in the skazki; Patrick Domico’s Medtner the Symbolist (2025) investigates the composer’s intellectual and religious context; and Chang Miao’s 2026 dissertation explicitly compares the spiritual and aesthetic orientations of Medtner, Scriabin, and Rachmaninoff. The problem of Medtner’s philosophical modernity is consequently a substantial existing research field, not an empty frontier.
The music-theoretical precedent is equally important. Janet Schmalfeldt’s In the Process of Becoming (2011) demonstrates how a passage’s formal function can emerge through later events and require retrospective reinterpretation. Theories of expectation and memory developed by Leonard Meyer (1956), David Huron (2006), and Elizabeth Hellmuth Margulis (2018) likewise prevent the present proposal from treating temporal understanding as a newly identified phenomenon. If the chapter is to contribute anything, it must specify an analytical distinction not already exhausted by the terms cyclic form, repetition, recall, or formal becoming.
The residual question is narrower and more demanding. When an earlier musical event returns or becomes implicated in a later one, does the later context simply identify a thematic relation, does it revise the earlier event’s formal function, or does it alter the plausible expressive interpretation of that event? These outcomes are not equivalent. A listener may recognize an idea without changing what it seemed to express; may revise a section’s formal identity without attributing a different expressive character to it; or may re-hear an unchanged motif as emotionally different because it now belongs to an altered context. This last possibility supplies the center of the present inquiry.
The overlooked performance tradition and a stronger originality objection
The previous literature review underestimated performance-based scholarship. Christopher John Miranda’s 2016 Indiana University doctoral essay, Nikolai Medtner: Performing Imagination in His Sonata Reminiscenza, Op. 38 No. 1, offers an extended reading of the sonata’s motivic, gestural, and affective organization through a pianist’s interpretive practice. It already describes the unexpected new theme within the recapitulation, the transformation of familiar material, and the relation between perceived return and changing affect. In discussing the sonata’s final gestures, Miranda explicitly interprets the return of the opening as altered by the emotional journey of the intervening music (Miranda 2016, especially pp. 55–71). Any attempt to attribute the mere idea of an emotionally transformed recurrence to this chapter would therefore repeat a published doctoral interpretation.
Evgeniya B. Tarasova’s substantial 2023 Russian-language pedagogical monograph, devoted to Op. 38 as a unified piano cycle, offers a second adverse precedent. The text traces motivic seeds from the sonata into the following movements and addresses thematic linkage, form, and performance decisions. Its existence and 88-page extent are confirmed in the Russian Gnessin Academy of Music’s official 2023 publication catalogue; a text copy allows preliminary inspection of its internal analysis. The present chapter neither claims to supersede its detailed pedagogical treatment nor treats performer-oriented scholarship as theoretically negligible. The complete publication must be assessed before an absolute originality verdict is defensible.
Miranda and Tarasova change the theoretical ceiling. A general assertion that the return of a Medtner theme is emotionally different from its first appearance would fail to be novel. The candidate contribution must instead specify when a changed expressive understanding is distinguishable from an analyst’s metaphor, and how that claim would be demonstrated or refuted by listeners. The theoretical object shifts from the critic’s interpretation of thematic narrative to the conditions for warranting a causal claim about retrospective interpretation. This distinction is narrower but intellectually more rigorous.
Byron Almén’s A Theory of Musical Narrative (2008) compounds the priority challenge at the level of theory. His framework makes narrative transformation, order, and culturally situated interpretation central analytical problems; it is not sufficient to say that Medtner creates ‘a story in time.’ The hypothesis here is deliberately orthogonal: it asks whether listeners revise a prior construal in response to context, even if the work affords no stable narrative agent or plot. That conceptual separation is a proposed argument, not an established priority claim. The complete comparison with Almén and the Rizzi chapter remains unfinished.
The more serious precedence of semantic interpretation
A further adverse source considerably narrows the philosophical claim. E. O. Predvechnova’s 2021 article, ‘Semantic Analysis-Interpretation on Example Sonata-Reminiscenza a-minor, Op. 38, No. 1 by N. K. Medtner,’ proposes a five-stage approach organized around programme, genre, composition, thematic meaning and performance. Its Russian text and English abstract explicitly interpret the music through temporal categories of present and past, symbolic images of memory and eternity, and the differing expressive possibilities of performances by Evgeny Svetlanov and Evgeny Kissin (Predvechnova 2021, 43–51). Thus a claim that Medtner’s sonata invites a philosophical interpretation of time, remembering, or altered affect has well-established antecedents in Russian scholarship as well as Western work.
Predvechnova’s methodological position is not identical to the present proposal. She develops a semantic-hermeneutic reading in which programme, cultural context, thematic process and performance contribute to an interpretation of symbolic musical images. The present chapter instead asks how to distinguish a hearer’s context-dependent revision of an earlier construal from a scholar’s subsequent attribution of expressive meaning. Neither approach is automatically superior. A semantically rich reading can illuminate artistic possibilities that a rigid experiment would miss; conversely, a controlled test can adjudicate whether a claimed listener effect occurs. These are different evidentiary tasks, and the proposed RSR category deserves retention only if it sharpens that distinction.
The scholarly problem is even wider. Daniel Beller-McKenna’s ‘Imagination and Memory: Inter-movement Thematic Recall in Beethoven and Brahms’ (published online 2021) traces historically differentiated meanings of returning material. His analysis includes Brahms’s Third Piano Sonata, Op. 5, in which the ‘Rückblick’ movement recontextualizes a theme from the preceding Andante, and later chamber works in which reprise can suggest loss and historical distance. This directly precedes any general thesis that a returning melody can acquire changed expressive implications. A claim of Medtnerian priority in this mechanism is indefensible. The remaining research question concerns particular combinations of formal, contextual and listening procedures, not the ownership of retrospection.
The two collection chapters that most directly address the present corpus, Nicolò Rizzi’s ‘Memory and Oblivion’ (pp. 49–94) and Tatyana Shevchenko’s performance study (pp. 39–48), are verifiably identified in the publisher’s table of contents but explicitly marked as inaccessible through the consulted public preview. ResearchGate likewise lists Rizzi’s chapter without offering full text. The responsible conclusion is not that their arguments can be reconstructed from titles or that their absence establishes novelty. They remain a material priority limitation. The current interpretation is therefore framed as a testable articulation and synthesis; no exclusive authorship or conceptual first claim is made pending their full examination.
Specific boundaries of the revised contribution
The contribution must be tested against four already-occupied territories. Formal reinterpretation in Schmalfeldt explains how an event’s function can become apparent only in retrospect. Narrative theory, including Almén and Beller-McKenna, addresses transformations in the perceived significance of earlier themes. Medtner scholarship, including Gheorghieva, Miranda, Rizzi, Tarasova and Predvechnova, already treats remembrance, affect and performance as dimensions of Op. 38. Musical cognition identifies attention, prediction, repetition and familiarization as possible mechanisms. RSR advances beyond these positions only if it specifies a narrower observable difference and proves that this difference is not fully explained by them. Its definition should therefore be understood as an operational research construct with deliberately limited originality claims.
That restriction changes the philosophical force of the chapter. An exciting metaphor—music causing us to understand the past again—is easy to produce and difficult to disconfirm. A research construct is valuable precisely when an analyst can identify cases where an aesthetically striking return fails the definition. Brahms’s Rückblick, Schubert’s Wanderer Fantasy, Liszt’s B-minor Sonata and Rachmaninoff’s Op. 36 are not background ornaments: they are cases that may show the proposed mechanism is widespread, differently organized, or too weakly specified to justify a Medtner-specific conclusion.
03The analytical distinction: retrospective status revision
I use the term retrospective status revision (RSR) for a specific and limited phenomenon: after encountering later musical context, a listener assigns a different interpretive status to an earlier, recognizable event, and that difference cannot be reduced to recognition, increased familiarity, or a changed formal label alone. “Status” is more cautious than “meaning”: instrumental music rarely fixes the semantic content of an utterance with linguistic precision, and listeners can reasonably disagree about a theme’s expressive character. The title’s “second hearing” does not require the literal repetition of a performance. It can designate an interpretive return to a passage during an uninterrupted first encounter with the work, as well as a new understanding made possible by listening again. These are distinct temporal situations and must be distinguished in experimental analysis.
The distinction has four components. Token identity concerns the perceptual recognition of a recurring gesture or theme. Structural function concerns a passage’s formal task within a movement or cycle. Expressive construal concerns how the passage is heard as urgent, resigned, hopeful, unsettled, conclusive, or otherwise qualified, without supposing universal emotional codes. Interpretive status concerns which of these readings is provisionally warranted at a particular point in listening. RSR occurs only when later context modifies the fourth component in a way attributable to the work’s relationships, not just to a listener’s growing fluency.
A simple counterexample clarifies the burden of proof. Suppose an eight-measure melody returns verbatim after a contrasting middle section. The return may be beautiful, and listeners may recognize it, but nothing yet shows that they have revised their interpretation of its first appearance. Likewise, a shift from minor to major does not, by itself, establish recovery, redemption, or reconciliation. The later harmony may change the expressive possibilities of the melody, but it is the responsibility of an analyst to identify how, and to admit where an interpretation exceeds what the notes justify.
I propose three minimum conditions for a credible RSR analysis. There must be an identifiable earlier construal, whether indicated by formal expectations or documented through listeners’ reports; later material must introduce a specific relationship that plausibly bears on that construal; and the resulting shift must differ from recognition or increased liking. Without all three conditions, an interpretation of the “past made new” remains a metaphor. This criterion also prevents the notion from becoming a universal compliment bestowed upon every work whose materials recur.
The concept does not require that the earlier impression was a mistake. A provisional interpretation may be justified by the information then available. Later material can make another interpretation preferable without falsifying the first. This feature distinguishes retrospective status revision from a simple theory of musical surprise. Surprise concerns a divergence between prediction and event; RSR concerns the possibility that the event changes the listener’s understanding of something already heard. Surprise can prompt revision, but the two are not identical.
This is the proposed conceptual advance, and it remains conditional. Its originality lies, at most, in the particular taxonomy and a research design for distinguishing these processes in Medtner and his peers. It would be unsound to claim that Medtner discovered retrospectivity, or that the named taxonomy is unanticipated by all existing cognitive theories. The terminology is useful only if it sharpens analysis and enables disconfirmation.
04The source history of Op. 38: the cycle is a revised artifact
The 1922 form of Forgotten Melodies I cannot be treated as a timeless container into which Medtner placed eight predetermined pieces. The Moscow programme of 28 January 1921 lists six entries, the last an Alla Coda linked to its preceding Canzona; the early cycle is also described as five compositions with an attached coda. Medtner then reworked the material and order, adding pieces and changing adjacency. The Berlin performance of April 1922 presents the expanded sequence, and the 1922 Zimmermann first edition retains the final title ‘Coda. Alla Reminiscenza’ beneath seven numbered pieces. These distinctions among programme, manuscript grouping, printed numbering, and audible components must be kept explicit (Shin 2018, 47–55; first-edition title page, Sibley Music Library).
This source history matters more than a retrospective biographical gloss about exile. It shows that the cycle’s final architecture was the result of compositional and editorial decisions. As an interpretation, the order of the published cycle can therefore be investigated for the kinds of recognition it makes possible. As historical evidence, the revisions do not themselves reveal why every alteration was made, and they should not be used to invent a private psychological motive. An artist who rearranges a cycle may be responding to duration, contrast, performance practicability, or other concerns; a defensible argument cannot treat the existence of revision as automatic proof of a philosophical programme.
The important fact for this chapter is structural: in the eight-piece edition, thematic materials from Sonata-Reminiscenza recur elsewhere in the sequence, and the final Alla reminiscenza resumes the reminiscence theme under a different tonal and rhythmic profile. That arrangement makes the listener’s encounter with the opening theme contingent upon an extended intervening musical history. The final form of the cycle is thus not just background to the analysis; it is part of the object analyzed.
A dissertation-quality continuation would compare the 1921 programme and surviving materials with the 1922 first edition and subsequent critical editions line by line. This chapter does not pretend to have performed that collation. It relies on Shin’s documentary reconstruction, states that dependence, and limits its historical inference accordingly. The inference that survives is modest but consequential: the published cycle offers opportunities for nested recollection that cannot be assessed by considering its first sonata alone.
Genetic chronology and the misleading simplicity of ‘eight movements’
The documentary record permits a sharper historical statement than the version previously offered. Medtner performed an early configuration at the Moscow Conservatory on 28 January 1921 under the programme designation ‘Forgotten Motives’ from the cycle Nature; the listed contents included an Alla Coda tied to the closing Canzona. In the performance and publication history of 1922, the cycle was substantially expanded and resequenced. Crucially, the final Coda is already present in the early programme: Medtner did not simply invent the return at the end of a mature, eight-part retrospective design. What changed was the material between the original sonata and the closing recollection, and with it the set of relationships capable of being perceived across the cycle (Shin 2018, 47–55).
This changes the causal story available to the analyst. It would be inaccurate to claim that the entire architecture of retrospective return first emerged in 1922. The earlier cycle already entertained a closing return. The more interesting historical hypothesis is that the revised ordering altered the contextual horizon of that return. Yet its purpose remains uncertain. Source history can establish the alteration, and music analysis can map its effects, but the composer’s precise intention cannot be inferred without corroborating testimony.
The strongest documentary question for a future genetic study is therefore differential rather than teleological: in what ways do the 1921 Canzona–Alla Coda adjacency and the 1922 Danza silvestra–Alla reminiscenza adjacency create different opportunities for thematic linkage and expressive framing? Shin has already demonstrated that the revised Danza silvestra takes on a different ending and that the relocation of Canzona changes its tonal position. A further contribution would involve an independent side-by-side analytical apparatus, built from surviving early materials, the 1922 publication, and the Zen-On edition’s documented variants. That apparatus is not yet produced here.
An actionable archival dossier, with claims kept separate from documents
The outstanding archival question is now specified at the collection level rather than invoked as an abstract need for ‘more sources.’ The Library of Congress holds the Nikolay Karlovich Medtner Papers, Music Division, ML31.M43: approximately 2,500 items in eleven containers, including correspondence, concert programmes, printed scores, books and three autograph manuscript scores. The published finding aid describes more than 1,900 letters, concentrated between 1914 and 1954, and identifies correspondence with Sergei and Nataliia Rachmaninoff, Alfred J. Swan, Leon and Olga Conus, Madeleine Laliberté and others. This catalogue establishes repository, extent and possible routes of investigation; it does not establish that any letter refers to the formal design of Op. 38. A claim about compositional intent requires inspecting an identifiable item, verifying authorship and date, and citing its container and folder. The current chapter makes no such claim.
The British Library’s Edna Iles Medtner Collection, MS Mus. 1748, contains manuscripts and correspondence, including scores displaying Medtner’s practice of drafting in pencil before Anna Medtner inked the copy, sometimes effacing the pencil. That process makes it particularly hazardous to treat a surviving neat manuscript as a transparent record of first conception. The archive is an appropriate target for the comparative genealogy of performance markings, but its catalogue alone does not provide evidence that a particular passage of Sonata-Reminiscenza received a late change. MS Mus. 1748/2/1/1, containing letters from the Medtners to Edna Iles, is a useful point of entry for questions about pianistic emphasis, but again cannot be converted into testimony until the letters are inspected.
The Library of Congress finding aid also names the Glinka Museum in Moscow, with a concentration of pre-1921 material; the Alfred Laliberté fonds at Library and Archives Canada; the Alfred Swan Papers at the University of Virginia; and the University of Leeds holdings. For Op. 38, the most useful question is whether manuscripts or annotated exemplars document the relation between the Moscow 1921 sequence and the Zimmermann 1922 text. Source-critical study should record each witness, its dating and physical state, the authority of editorial interventions, and the degree of uncertainty introduced where pencil layers have been obliterated. Shin’s earlier examination of unpublished Glinka materials and annotations is prior scholarly work, not independent archival access achieved in this revision.
A narrowly formulated archive request would seek (i) descriptions or images of identifiable Op. 38 manuscript leaves; (ii) correspondence dated 1919–22 mentioning the cycle, its ordering, or publication; (iii) annotated copies bearing authorial revisions; and (iv) performing instructions that can be tied securely to a particular textual witness. An archival witness that demonstrates only a change in notational presentation should not be pressed into evidence that Medtner intended a distinctive philosophy of retrospection. This dossier converts a missing research domain into a replicable plan while preserving the distinction between discovery in a catalogue and examination of historical artifacts.
Reading the original edition as an independent textual witness
The 1922 Zimmermann print is available in a public-domain copy preserved by the Sibley Music Library, University of Rochester. A direct visual check of the score’s title page confirms seven numbered pieces followed by ‘Coda. Alla Reminiscenza’; the first page of the sonata establishes the initial Allegretto tranquillo with an added andantino con moto indication, in 2/4, and its opening instruction p semplice. The final page of the sonata shows a renewed introductory-type texture, marked molto tranquillo, ma mobile e egualmente, concluding with the pronounced final cadence. These are observations made from the published score pages, rather than deductions from later commentators. They permit a modest claim about outer framing and expressive direction, not an inference that a listener necessarily reinterprets the opening.
This visual verification corrects the evidentiary provenance of three assertions: the coda designation is primary-source evidence; the notated initial expressive character is primary-source evidence; and the written return near the close is visibly present. It does not independently certify every measure number in Shin’s formal tables, reconstruct autograph layers, or settle the authority of 1959 editorial revisions. Claims beyond the directly inspected pages remain explicitly dependent on named published analyses and a specialist edition concordance.
05Sonata-Reminiscenza: a return complicated by the arrival of the new
The introduction and the first distinction between local closure and global function
The A-minor Sonata-Reminiscenza begins with an eight-measure introductory reminiscence idea, marked by restrained lyrical movement and local coherence. Shin describes this introduction as a structurally separate entity rather than a conventional Beethovenian introduction gathering unresolved tension into the exposition. The first principal thematic group begins around measure 17. The melodic and rhythmic relationship between the opening and subsequent materials renders the opening both individually recognizable and relevant to the broader organization of the work (Shin 2018, 63–66).
That dual character makes the introduction a useful test case. A locally coherent opening need not be globally self-explanatory. Its later thematic relationships may confer on it a generative significance that was not evident during its first hearing. But the score supports only the existence of those relationships; it cannot establish that listeners first hear the idea as self-contained or later interpret it differently. The analytical gain consists in identifying a possible discrepancy between the presentation’s local identity and its subsequently disclosed function, not in attributing a fixed psychology of remembering to every audience.
The second exposition is a difference-producing return
At measure 92 Medtner annotated the beginning of what he called a double exposition. In the first rotation, a secondary theme has already appeared; the second rotation partly revisits the first but introduces another secondary theme rather than simply repeating all preceding material. Shin preserves Medtner’s note and maps the thematic groups (2018, 63–70). The detail is important because “second exposition” names a retrospective formal act that also contains a forward-looking disclosure. It is at once a return to established thematic territory and the presentation of something not yet heard.
A conventional expositional repeat permits familiarity and reconsideration; here the second rotation frustrates the expectation that reiteration will duplicate a settled inventory. The first presentation, retrospectively, cannot stand as a complete statement of the secondary thematic possibilities. This is not a wholly unprecedented sonata procedure, and the claim of novelty at the level of formal design belongs to Bitzan and Shin rather than to this chapter. The interpretive question is different: whether the changed second rotation leads a listener to revise the initial status of the first as a complete exposition, and whether that change matters expressively rather than only classificatorily.
Counterpoint is an argument about relationship, not automatically an argument about memory
In the development, Medtner brings themes that first appeared successively into contrapuntal proximity. Shin identifies a consequential combination of materials around measures 198–205. When themes coexist that were previously encountered apart, the listener may apprehend a relation not salient at either first presentation. Yet the move from successive appearance to simultaneous combination establishes thematic interdependence before it establishes interpretive revision. The strongest reading is therefore not “counterpoint makes the past meaningful,” a formulation too broad to test, but that the combination supplies new information that might qualify a previously independent construal of the thematic groups.
A skeptical reading is fully available: expert listeners may perceive conventional motivic workmanship rather than a changed emotional or interpretive identity. This is precisely why the third condition of RSR cannot be assumed from an analytical diagram. The distinction between the score’s potential and actual uptake must remain intact.
The recapitulation violates an easy equation of return with restoration
The recapitulation beginning near measure 277 is the movement’s strongest local case. As Shin’s formal table shows, the return of the principal group is followed by a newly introduced theme, subsequently designated T4, in the region of measures 299–322; the new thematic phrase itself enters around measure 301. The score marks its distinctive character poco giocoso, ma sempre espressivo. This is neither a straightforward restoration of prior thematic materials nor an entirely developmental interruption. It is novelty within the portion of the form most strongly associated with re-presentation (Shin 2018, 73–74).
The novelty matters because it alters the logic of what the recapitulation can be expected to do. The recapitulation does not simply inventory what has already been known; it produces a new condition for interpreting the material around it. Yet no simple ideological conclusion follows. The new, lighter character is not unambiguous evidence of redemption, just as the surrounding minor-mode material is not a determinate autobiographical confession. The warranted observation is formal and contextual: Medtner locates an expressive alternative within a section whose conventional name emphasizes return.
The introductory reminiscence theme eventually returns to close the movement. On one plausible hearing, its renewed presence can be inflected by the work’s now-expanded thematic landscape. On another, the return may be perceived chiefly as framing, symmetry, or closure. The score permits both responses. RSR identifies the narrower situation in which the former experience is demonstrably induced by the intervening material. The close reading thus establishes a researchable question rather than announcing a psychological fact.
06The nested return: from Sonata-Reminiscenza to Alla reminiscenza
The eight-piece Op. 38 cycle supplies a longer temporal horizon than the opening sonata. Shin establishes that the reminiscence theme recurs in Canzona serenata and in the final Alla reminiscenza, and that thematic material designated T3 returns near the close of Danza silvestra before recurring within the concluding piece. Danza silvestra leads attacca into Alla reminiscenza. Thus the same network of thematic identities is active across both the opening and the end of the cycle (Shin 2018, 108–14).
The formal arrangement deserves attention to its exact sequencing. T3 is heard at the end of the penultimate work, and the reminiscence theme opens the last. Within Alla reminiscenza, thematic materials are juxtaposed again; the closing piece is marked quasi coda, and the opening reminiscence melody appears in A major. The relation between the A-minor beginning and the A-major ending is readily described as transformation, but its importance is not exhausted by a familiar change of mode. The last theme is heard after several intervening genres and expressive environments that an isolated performance of the sonata would omit.
Shin’s discussion adds specific technical reasons not to collapse this return into a simple minor-to-major narrative. The final piece’s opening restatement uses changed accompaniment and slower harmonic rhythm; a bass line with chromatic descent contributes to its character. Later expansion of the melody includes a raised fourth scale degree and an enlarged registral trajectory (Shin 2018, 111–14). These details produce a materially different sounding environment for a theme that remains recognizable. They do not, on their own, establish an emotional story of resignation overcome by joy.
The most productive analytic hypothesis is that the cycle enables an encounter between a recognized opening theme and a later statement whose harmonic, textural, accompanimental, and formal conditions differ. This is compatible with retrospective status revision, but it is not sufficient evidence for it. The exact conditions matter: the 1922 edition treats the return as a coda and the cycle’s order was materially revised after the early 1921 performance. A listener’s changed construal, if any, must be established separately from the demonstrable differences between the original and returning statements.
The historically revised status of the cycle strengthens this reading without proving intent. The published ordering places these encounters in a particular sequence. But the analyst must resist a teleological story in which the final A major is assumed to reveal the composer’s true intention at the opening. A different order might elicit different experiences, and that possibility becomes a way of testing the hypothesis rather than a threat to the interpretation.
The 1922 coda and the non-neutrality of editions
One apparently small bibliographic detail changes the way the cycle should be described. The 1922 Zimmermann first edition, preserved in the University of Rochester’s Sibley Music Library, prints seven numbered titles and then ‘Coda. Alla Reminiscenza’ on the title page. Modern listings frequently describe eight pieces and call the last ‘No. 8,’ which is convenient for cataloguing but does not reproduce the original title-page hierarchy. The distinction does not erase the eight component performances; it makes the coda’s dependent relation to the cycle visible in the material artifact itself. A theory about return ought not quietly normalize away the composer’s and publisher’s original designation of the returning music as a coda.
The early and later states raise a further distinction. The 1921 Moscow programme listed Sonata reminiscenza, Danza graziosa, Danza silvestra, Danza festiva, Canzona, and Alla Coda; documentary reconstructions group the latter two in discussing the five-item early cycle. The later published sequence adds Canzona fluviala and Danza rustica, rearranges the dances, relocates and transforms the former Canzona into Canzona serenata, and links Danza silvestra to Alla reminiscenza. The difference between ‘five pieces including a coda’ and ‘six programme entries’ should not be treated as a contradiction: it reflects whether the dependent coda is counted as a separate composition. Shin’s early-versus-published table (2018, 52–55) and the Medtner reference catalogue support this reconstruction.
Neither the coda designation nor the changes of order prove retrospective status revision. They do, however, define the precise unit of musical analysis: a coda made to carry the recognizability of the opening theme after a deliberately reconfigured cycle. The alternation of contrast, recall, and thematic contiguity may change when performed as an eight-component whole rather than as an isolated sonata. That provides an empirically useful manipulation: the same opening can be revisited after the whole published cycle or after a suitably controlled intervening sequence, permitting one to ask what the intervening musical history actually contributes.
Edition variants also prevent unqualified statements about what a listener hears. A specialist collation at medtner.org.uk records that the 1922 and 1959 versions differ at Op. 38, No. 1, measure 206, where the original mp pertains to the left-hand theme, and at measures 415–426, where the 1959 edition prolongs lower right-hand A notes with ties absent in the 1922 text. The 1959 edition also supplies additional articulative or expressive instructions at measures 1, 17, 61, and elsewhere. These details can affect continuity, emphasis, and perceived voice leading at precisely the sorts of passages where a theory of recognition might be tested. The differences cited here derive from a published specialist edition comparison, not from my own exhaustive facsimile-to-urtext collation; they should be rechecked against the editions before notated examples are finalized.
This source-critical restraint matters philosophically. If a listening effect changes with editorial choices, the effect cannot automatically be ascribed to ‘Medtner’s timeless work.’ One would need to show either that the effect survives relevant performance and edition variants, or that it belongs to a specific historical text. The present research therefore treats edition as an independent variable, not a footnote to an abstract aesthetic proposition.
07Night Wind as a boundary case, not a confirmation
The E-minor Sonata, Op. 25, No. 2, known as Night Wind, offers a different problem of musical time. Its expanded single-movement architecture, interlocking formal processes, and density of motivic transformation are well established in Bitzan’s discussion. The title and its Tyutchev epigraph invite philosophical interpretation, as do the scholarship on Russian Symbolism and the composer’s professed defense of musical order. But these facts must not be treated as independent confirmation that Night Wind changes listeners’ interpretations of earlier passages. A piece can be difficult to follow without producing retrospective status revision, and a score can possess intricate relations that remain inaudible to listeners.
Night Wind should instead function as a boundary case for the proposed theory. Its fugal and sonata-related processes may invite gradually differentiated understanding on successive hearings, but that is an inquiry into perceptual learning and formal recognition as much as, or more than, a change in expressive construal. A listener’s discovery on the fifth hearing that a fugato derives from earlier material is not automatically evidence that the first hearing’s interpretation of that material has changed. The distinction protects the theory from turning Medtner’s technical demands into a guaranteed sign of philosophical depth.
The 2026 comparison by Chang Miao is especially pertinent. Miao interprets the piano sonata as a medium of divergent spiritual orientations during the Russian Silver Age and treats Medtner as invested in an ethical order of musical form, in contrast with Scriabin’s pursuit of transcendence and Rachmaninoff’s conflicts of exile and fragmentation. This thesis is not identical with RSR, but it creates a serious rival explanation for the salience of musical coherence in Night Wind. A rigorous study would test whether an analysis of retrospective interpretation adds explanatory power to existing formal, symbolic, and spiritual accounts. If it does not, the proposed concept should not be retained for rhetorical novelty.
08Rachmaninoff and the false comfort of contrast
The Second Piano Sonata, Op. 36, is the appropriate adversarial case because it subjects any “Medtner understands time; Rachmaninoff expresses feeling” thesis to direct pressure. Rachmaninoff’s sonata operates with recurring motivic material across its three connected movements and underwent a substantial authorial revision between its 1913 and 1931 versions. The differences are not limited to performance duration; they alter large-scale narrative relations. Carlson (2021) draws attention to those changes, and Ferrer (2025) argues for the expressive and structural significance of the earlier text. Konstantin Lapshin’s performance research also treats the 1931 sonata as a case of interpretation transforming over time. Rachmaninoff must consequently be approached as a composer of developed temporal relationships, not as an immediately legible opposite to Medtner.
Two comparisons should be kept separate. An intracompositional comparison asks what later events within one version of the sonata do to the perception of earlier material. A genetic comparison asks what the 1931 revision does to relationships established in the 1913 composition. A modern listener who hears both versions can retrospectively reinterpret the 1913 sonata after encountering the revision, but that is not the same psychological event as hearing a recurring theme within a single performance. The original chapter insufficiently distinguished these forms of retrospection.
A proper comparison should select matched events rather than rely upon undifferentiated contrasts between complete composers. Lasarenko’s measure-specific analysis of Rachmaninoff’s 1913 text identifies useful candidate passages: second-movement measures 16 and 28–35, third-movement measures 97, 232–234, and 258–260. These passages can be set against the Medtner double exposition, development, and cycle-level return, provided the different timescales and formal functions are not obscured. The passage selection is now explicit and supported by a documented analytical source. Independent concordance with original Rachmaninoff edition pages, notational reductions, and a common coding rubric are still required before any stronger comparative inference.
The falsifying possibility is straightforward: Rachmaninoff may produce stronger or more frequent changes in retrospective expressive judgment, while Medtner may elicit chiefly thematic recognition or formal learning. If this occurs, the hypothesis that RSR distinguishes Medtner from Rachmaninoff fails. The analysis of Op. 38 would retain its value as a local interpretation, but the thesis of comparative exceptionalism would have to be abandoned. This is not an embarrassing concession; it is the condition under which the comparison becomes scholarship rather than advocacy.
A provisional comparison now rests on documented passages on both sides. Medtner’s double exposition complicates thematic completeness; his recapitulation admits new thematic material; and his published cycle returns the opening idea through an expressly marked coda. Rachmaninoff’s 1913 sonata carries its opening motive into the second movement, superimposes it with a newly established theme, and combines material from the first and third movements near the culmination of the last (Lasarenko 1988, 29–39). Both composers thus create relationships whose later availability can matter for how earlier material is understood. What remains unproven is a systematic difference in interpretive effect rather than in structural procedure.
A specified Rachmaninoff counterexample: the 1913 sonata
Kim Andrei Lasarenko’s detailed 1988 analysis supplies the concrete comparator that the earlier chapter lacked. His account of Rachmaninoff’s 1913 Second Sonata distinguishes opening-movement motive I-1-a from I-1-b and traces them through the later movements. The first movement begins with an assertive descending figure whose rhythmic and intervallic elements become generative. In the second movement, a fragment of I-1-b appears in the left hand at measure 16, while the new movement’s principal theme is superimposed on an augmented form of I-1-b over measures 28–35. Lasarenko identifies a reduction of the borrowed motive at measures 35–36 and its subsequent use in the movement’s central section (Lasarenko 1988, 29–32).
Rachmaninoff thereby does more than cite his opening: the material participates in new textures and assumes new thematic roles. A listener could plausibly hear the second movement as making the first movement’s motives available under a different expressive and functional description. This is the same kind of affordance the Medtner thesis seeks to identify. Its presence in Rachmaninoff is a substantive challenge, not an anomalous exception.
The third movement makes the challenge sharper. Lasarenko identifies the recurrence of opening motive I-1-a at measure 97, a later fragment of I-1-b in the soprano at measures 232–234, and, at measures 258–260, the combination of I-1-a with motive III-1-b (1988, 34, 38–39). The last example resembles, at an abstract level, Medtner’s combination of previously introduced thematic materials around measures 198–205 in Sonata-Reminiscenza: material heard earlier is integrated with another thematic identity, and the resulting simultaneity can alter how the parts relate. The procedures are not identical in dramatic scale, source location, or compositional syntax, and they should not be treated as interchangeable. What this comparison establishes is that Rachmaninoff cannot be assigned the role of ‘immediate feeling’ against Medtner’s ‘retrospective intelligence.’
These measure locations are taken from Lasarenko’s annotated exposition of the 1913 text, which numbers the movements according to his stated scheme. They have been checked against the accessible dissertation and its musical examples; they have not yet been independently collated with a physical Gutheil first edition or a modern critical score. That degree of source dependence must remain visible. The point is not to claim a finished two-score analysis, but to replace an empty comparative placeholder with falsifying primary repertoire, a concrete source, and explicitly delimited analytical claims.
The conceptual comparison is now tractable. Medtner’s op. 38 juxtaposes a modified second exposition, novelty within recapitulation, and cycle-level return in a final coda. Rachmaninoff’s op. 36 redistributes an opening motive across movement boundaries and combines it with later themes. An experimental test could ask not whether either work has thematic unity, which both plainly do, but whether audiences re-evaluate the expressive or functional standing of the original motive after its later appearance, and whether different procedures prompt different kinds of re-evaluation. An outcome showing no composer difference would qualify the language of Medtner’s exceptionality without erasing his formal inventiveness.
A necessary non-equivalence: work, edition, performance
At least three timescales must be separated before making claims about a second hearing. Within-work recurrence concerns the ordering of events inside one performance. Genetic revision concerns Rachmaninoff’s 1931 recomposition of the 1913 work: one score may be interpreted against another, but the listener is engaging two versions, not one unfolding sequence. Interpretive revision concerns performances of the same notated text, whose voicing, articulation, tempo and pedaling can foreground or obscure thematic relationships. The scores condition these possibilities; they do not exhaust them.
The 1931 revisions to Rachmaninoff’s Second Sonata, documented by Lasarenko and more recent analyses, compress passages and change textural density in ways that may affect the perceptibility of themes and transitions. Medtner’s editions likewise differ at specific dynamic and tying details. A comparison that treats ‘Rachmaninoff’ and ‘Medtner’ as single invariant acoustic stimuli would conflate composer, edition, and performer. The proposed research must therefore identify exact editions and recordings and, ideally, test whether any inferred effect remains under more than one performance.
Brahms, Schubert, and Liszt: the comparison Medtner cannot evade
A comparative thesis confined to Medtner and Rachmaninoff is too narrow to establish a distinctive twentieth-century form of retrospectivity. The larger Romantic inheritance already contains works that organize thematic recognition and expressive return. Three negative comparators clarify the burden: Brahms’s Third Piano Sonata, Op. 5, Schubert’s Wanderer Fantasy, D. 760, and Liszt’s Sonata in B minor. None is presented here as an exhaustive alternative corpus; each is a prespecified case whose procedures could disconfirm the proposition that Medtner’s strategy is unique.
Brahms, Piano Sonata No. 3 in F minor, Op. 5 (1853), movements II and IV. The fourth movement bears the title Rückblick (Retrospect) and evokes the Andante’s thematic material under transformed expressive circumstances. As Daniel Beller-McKenna observes in a 2021 study of memory in Beethoven and Brahms, the return engages the Andante’s poetic frame and creates a narrative association with absence, lost love and mortality. These associations belong to an established interpretive literature; the present chapter does not claim to discover them. The formal procedure is a serious alternative to any Medtner-centered story: a theme may carry recognizable identity while the later movement changes its expressive setting and the listener’s relation to earlier material. An RSR account would have to demonstrate that a listener’s judgment of the original Andante changes after hearing Rückblick, rather than simply that the fourth movement is perceived as dark, commemorative or thematically related.
Schubert, Wanderer Fantasy in C major, D. 760 (1822), opening Allegro, Adagio variations, Presto scherzo and concluding fugue. The four contiguous sections transform the rhythmic and melodic material associated with Der Wanderer into contrasting structural roles. A motive that initially appears in a forceful Allegro is subsequently understood in relation to the song-derived lyrical theme and becomes the basis of dance and fugato procedures. The existence of these relationships is well documented, and the work plainly defeats any assertion that Medtner alone made returning material relevant to progressively available formal knowledge. It also provides a useful negative test: a hearer may recognize cyclic transformation and report increased coherence without changing their interpretation of the opening. The distinction between thematic metamorphosis and interpretive revision becomes empirically examinable rather than terminological.
Liszt, Piano Sonata in B minor, S. 178 (1853), as a case of double formal function. Work on Liszt’s sonata, particularly Steven Vande Moortele’s two-dimensional account and David Falterman’s methodological extension, shows how a single work can sustain overlapping sonata and sonata-cycle interpretations. The same stretch of music may be differently classified according to the formal level under consideration. This is an especially important countercase because it emphasizes formal reinterpretation without necessitating a changed emotional evaluation of earlier themes. If listeners’ responses to Liszt are chiefly formal, their pattern would favor Schmalfeldt-style becoming over RSR; if their emotional construal also changes, Medtner’s distinctiveness becomes harder to defend.
These cases must not be homogenized. Brahms’s Rückblick offers explicit expressive retrospection across movements; Schubert’s Wanderer Fantasy develops a cyclic motive across contrasting continuous sections; and Liszt’s sonata admits partly simultaneous levels of formal interpretation. Medtner’s Op. 38, by contrast, places a modified double exposition, novelty in recapitulation and a subsequently recontextualized coda within a cycle whose contents and ordering were revised historically. Their differences justify analytical comparison. They do not justify a ranking of genius, or the claim that one procedure is automatically more philosophically sophisticated than another.
A comparative classification should therefore record for each passage the number and distance of returns, mode and harmonic changes, textural transformation, formal role, prior expositional status, and strength of cross-reference. Separately, it should measure whether listeners revise an earlier expressive construal. These two matrices must be analyzed independently before their association can be assessed. Medtner could prove unusual in his combination of techniques without producing larger cognitive effects; Brahms or Rachmaninoff could prove more powerful in listeners’ retrospective reinterpretation. Such results are legitimate outcomes, not reasons to redefine the construct after the fact.
The critical-edition warning: Rachmaninoff’s sources and counting conventions
Dominik Rahmer’s critical commentary to the Henle Urtext edition of Rachmaninoff’s Op. 36 provides a firmer source basis for genetic claims than generalized statements about a long and short version. It identifies an autograph of the original version at the Glinka Museum (Ф.18 № 103), sketches there under Ф.18 № 56, the Gutheil first edition announced in 1914 (plate A. 9695 G), and the revised Gutheil edition issued in November 1931 (plate A. 10447 G). The 1931 text was newly engraved, and even unchanged sections could acquire new errors. The critical edition treats each version separately rather than producing a hybrid.
A crucial counting distinction follows. The Henle commentary treats the slow movement and finale as one continuously numbered complex because the source notation passes directly from one to the other without conventional page or double-bar separation. Lasarenko’s measure references in the 1988 analytical dissertation belong to his chosen movement-wise scheme. They must not be transferred uncritically into a modern critical score’s running numbering. This is not pedantry: a work concerned with the status of musical events should not rely on ambiguous locators. The concordance in this chapter cites Lasarenko’s movement-specific scheme and records the need for a source-by-source crosswalk. No cross-edition equivalence of measure numbers is claimed until established.
The archive establishes one further methodological asymmetry: Rachmaninoff left an autograph with pencil corrections serving the first edition, whereas the 1931 revision is known principally through its authorized print, without a surviving comparable engraver’s exemplar identified in the Henle commentary. The two versions therefore do not permit identical genetic reconstruction. A comparative study must not describe uneven archives as if they furnished equivalent evidence about each composer’s intention.

09Philosophical stakes: interpretation without biographical mythology
Retrospective status revision suggests a philosophical proposition: temporal works can make the interpretation of earlier events dependent upon subsequently encountered relations. This proposition is not peculiar to music; it recalls features of narrative understanding, practical deliberation, and historical judgment. Yet its application to music must be constrained by the character of musical expression. Unlike a linguistic argument, a piano sonata usually does not assert determinate propositions; unlike an autobiography, a thematic return does not identify a particular remembered episode. The analogy between musical recollection and human memory is therefore structural, not literal.
The distinction between provisional and completed understanding is especially useful. A first hearing may license an interpretation that becomes less plausible after a later return. This need not render the first hearing false. It may show that the first hearing was epistemically situated: appropriate to a partial sequence of evidence, and open to revision when that sequence expands. A formally coherent musical work can create this condition without offering an unambiguous verbal message. The resulting experience is not “music teaching humility”; it is an occasion on which a listener may exercise the ordinary capacity to reconsider a provisional judgment.
There is a further temptation to infer normative consequences: perhaps listening to Medtner makes individuals more patient, more receptive to difference, or more intellectually humble. Nothing in the score establishes those outcomes. A transfer claim from aesthetic listening to social or moral conduct would require its own empirical demonstration and theoretical account of mechanisms. Music’s capacity to organize an experience of reconsideration is analytically interesting without being turned into a program of character formation. To avoid claiming an ethical benefit without evidence is not to impoverish the philosophy; it is to retain the difference between what music affords and what listeners do.
For similar reasons, Medtner’s aesthetic writings cannot be treated as transparent instructions for decoding his works. The Muse and the Fashion articulates a demanding defense of musical foundations and inherited principles. His commitments are historically indispensable, but they do not license a direct passage from a formal feature to a settled ideological meaning. A sonata may resist the composer’s explicit theory, exemplify it only partially, or invite interpretations he would have rejected. The score, the archive, and reception must be held in productive tension.
The proposed philosophical reward is more restricted and more defensible: it becomes possible to ask how an artwork organizes the warrant for an interpretation over time. The object of study is not memory in the abstract but a changing relationship between an earlier event and the interpretive claims made about it. If this is the right description, then musical innovation can be investigated in terms of distributed intelligibility as well as changes in style, harmony, or instrumental technique. That theoretical possibility is independent of the claim that Medtner was the first or best composer to realize it.
10A falsifiable programme of close analysis and listening research
Preregistration and stimulus construction
A defensible test would preregister the primary hypothesis, the analytical definition of RSR, participant exclusions, planned contrasts, and procedures for handling familiarity and musical expertise. The music would be presented in performance recordings whose tempo, dynamics, and editing are documented. Where excerpts are used, their boundaries should be musically justified and reviewed independently so that experimental manipulation does not create an artificial formal effect. A separate committee of trained analysts, blinded to the preferred hypothesis where feasible, would classify candidate moments as recognition-only, formal reinterpretation, proposed RSR, or ambiguous. Disagreements should be retained as evidence of interpretive uncertainty rather than resolved by authorial fiat.
The decisive experimental contrast would compare an initial target passage followed by its related later context with the same initial target followed by unrelated but stylistically appropriate context, and with repeated exposure to the target without intervening material. After the later context, participants would hear the target again and report their interpretation. Thus the primary measure is not whether a theme is identified correctly, but whether a context-specific change in its expressive construal occurs beyond the change attributable to familiarity alone. Randomized order and counterbalancing would mitigate sequence and fatigue effects.
Operational outcomes
The primary outcome could be the difference between first and second judgments on prespecified expressive dimensions, interpreted alongside a coded open-response explanation stating what changed and why. A revision should count as context-dependent only when the participant links it to a musical event in the intervening passage rather than simply asserting that the target now seems more familiar. Secondary outcomes should record recognition accuracy, confidence, perceived structural connectedness, surprise, liking, and musical training. These measures permit a critical discrimination: an effect of increased enjoyment or of formal recognition is not automatically an effect of revised expressive interpretation.
The main statistical comparison should estimate the interaction between composer, condition, and hearing, with participant and stimulus variation accounted for in a hierarchical model appropriate to the outcome scale. The plan must not treat a single movement as a random sample of a composer’s entire output. Claims about Medtner as a composer would require multiple works, independently chosen passages, and enough replication to separate composer-level from piece-level effects. Sample size and detectable effect thresholds must be established through a prospective power analysis after pilot estimates rather than invented here.
Disconfirming results
At least four results would qualify the thesis. If all conditions generate comparable shifts, the effect is likely general familiarization. If only recognition changes while expressive judgments remain stable, the RSR claim is unsupported. If a related context changes liking but not a participant’s articulated understanding of the earlier passage, the result should not be redescribed as interpretation. If Rachmaninoff’s passages equal or exceed Medtner’s on the preregistered contrast, the claim of Medtner’s comparative distinctiveness fails even if particular examples in Op. 38 remain compelling. The study should also permit genuine null results: an elaborate composition may not induce perceptible reinterpretation under ordinary listening conditions.
A mixed-method design would be preferable to a single questionnaire. Close score analysis would identify what later information is compositionally available; controlled listening would test context-sensitive revision; follow-up interviews might reveal how listeners explain that revision in their own terms. The three bodies of evidence should not be collapsed. An analyst’s identification of a motivic relationship is not equivalent to a participant’s reported experience, and a participant’s report is not a direct record of mental process. Their convergence would be informative precisely because each can fail independently.
The preregistered estimand and interpretive coding rules
A test of retrospective status revision requires a target quantity before any performance recording is played. For each participant and each passage, define a first-hearing expressive construal C₀ and a second construal C₁. The principal outcome is the occurrence and magnitude of a change in construal that the listener explicitly attributes to a musical relationship supplied during the intervening context. Let ΔRSR denote the difference between this change under related context and the same change under matched unrelated context. The operational definition must distinguish changes of emotion intensity from changes of interpretive status; scoring criteria should be frozen before condition labels are revealed. The symbol names a research variable, not an assumption that a single continuous psychological quantity already exists.
The primary comparison should be made at the passage level, with only a small set of prespecified categorical dimensions (for example, tentative/conclusive; independent/dependent; settled/unsettled) supplemented by brief free-text interpretation. Such scales are analytical prompts, not universal emotional codes. An independent coding panel would assign labels from a preregistered rubric to participants’ explanations, blind to the composer and listening condition. Agreement should be quantified, disagreements retained, and open-text disagreement examined rather than silently averaged away.
The first experimental stage would be a stimulus-validation pilot rather than a definitive Medtner-versus-Rachmaninoff experiment. Skilled analysts should rate whether passages are musically self-contained when truncated, whether a later excerpt contains a recognizable relation, and whether the extract still preserves the intended formal trajectory. Participants should separately report unfamiliarity with the work, musical education, and whether they detect the relation at all. Exclude only on prespecified grounds, not because an outcome contradicts the preferred thesis. A full performance condition should be included when excerpt editing risks creating misleading sense of formal closure.
The confirmatory model should estimate the context effect and its interaction with composer while allowing participant and stimulus heterogeneity; passage-level repeated measures and response-scale properties determine the exact statistical specification. If the passages have not been sampled in a way that represents the composers’ wider output, the conclusion must remain about those passages. A stronger composer-level generalization demands a multi-work corpus and a defensible sampling strategy. The study must include a sensitivity analysis in which the proposed effect is required to survive controls for recognition, familiarity, and increased liking.
There is no legitimate numerical result to report in this version. Human-subjects approval where required, participant recruitment, pilot effect estimates, preregistration, data collection, and analysis are still future operations. That limitation is not a small formatting defect. It is the boundary between a theoretical hypothesis and the empirical discovery the strongest version of the chapter would need.
Analytical concordance: observation, inference, and evidentiary limit
Case M1 — Medtner, Sonata-Reminiscenza, mm. 1–8 and from m. 17. Documentary basis: Shin (2018, 63–66) and the published score. Observation: the opening reminiscence idea is locally articulate, and subsequently introduced themes share elements of its musical vocabulary. Inference: a listener may reinterpret the opening as generative of later material. Limit: neither formal relatedness nor apparent initial completeness proves an experienced change of expressive construal.
Case M2 — Medtner, Sonata-Reminiscenza, second exposition from m. 92 and new secondary material from approximately m. 118. Documentary basis: Medtner’s note as reproduced by Shin (2018, 63–70). Observation: the second expositional rotation is abbreviated and supplies material absent from the first. Inference: the later rotation may affect a listener’s view of what counted as a sufficient initial exposition. Limit: this is first a question of formal expectations, not necessarily RSR.
Case M3 — Medtner, Sonata-Reminiscenza, thematic combination around mm. 198–205. Documentary basis: Shin (2018, analytical tables and examples). Observation: previously separate material occurs in contrapuntal combination. Inference: successive thematic ideas can become relationally understood. Limit: the procedure is common in other composers and may amount to motivic recognition alone.
Case M4 — Medtner, Sonata-Reminiscenza, recapitulation from m. 277, new material around mm. 299–322, and concluding reminiscence return around mm. 415–430. Documentary basis: Shin (2018, 73–74) and edition concordance; the return is subject to documented 1922/1959 variants. Observation: thematic novelty and recapitulation coexist. Inference: ‘return’ may not mean exhaustive restitution of a previously settled theme inventory. Limit: a conceptual formal inference cannot fix the listener’s emotional response.
Case M5 — Medtner, Op. 38, Danza silvestra ending and the linked opening of the Coda, Alla reminiscenza, mm. 1–8 and 21–38. Documentary basis: Shin (2018, 109–14) and the 1922 Zimmermann first-edition title page. Observation: T3 precedes the return of the opening reminiscence idea; the coda transforms it in A major and later expands it. Inference: the cycle creates nested thematic recollection and a changed tonal/expressive environment. Limit: it does not by itself establish redemption, autobiographical memory, or a revised interpretation in listeners.
Case R1 — Rachmaninoff, Second Sonata, 1913 first edition, first movement m. 1 and second movement mm. 16, 28–35. Documentary basis: Lasarenko (1988, 17–18, 29–32). Observation: first-movement motivic elements recur, and a second-movement theme is superimposed upon an augmented borrowed motive. Inference: the present can reorganize relationships attributed to the earlier movement. Limit: independently checking the published Gutheil score and controlling for performance editions are necessary before precise cross-composer claims.
Case R2 — Rachmaninoff, same 1913 text, third movement mm. 97, 232–234, and 258–260. Documentary basis: Lasarenko (1988, 34, 38–39). Observation: a motif from movement I recurs and subsequently combines with material of movement III. Inference: Medtner cannot be contrasted with Rachmaninoff on the bare existence of cross-temporal thematic relations. Limit: similarity at the level of abstract technique is not proof of equivalent listener experience.
Case V1 — Textual/performative variant. Medtner Sonata-Reminiscenza m. 206 and mm. 415–426 differ between reported 1922 and 1959 readings; Rachmaninoff Op. 36 has authorial 1913 and 1931 texts. Documentary basis: Medtner reference-site collation; Lasarenko (1988); IMSLP first-edition records. Inference: the audible prominence and continuity of thematic strands can be edition-sensitive. Limit: each recording and score must be identified precisely; no abstract unperformed score provides a unique acoustic stimulus.
The concordance deliberately does not include numerical effect sizes, invented score reductions, or claims of first-hand autograph inspection. Its contribution is procedural: each proposed interpretive consequence is tethered to a specific work location, a cited analytical source, and an explicit limit of inference. A publishable version should replace this textual concordance with notated examples checked against the source editions and an independent systematic comparison.
A ready-to-review pilot protocol (proposed, not executed)
Design. This chapter now specifies a prospective three-condition, repeated-measures listening pilot. The unit of assignment is a participant–target passage pair, and the outcome is the difference between an initial interpretation and an interpretation elicited after further music. In condition R (related context), the target is followed by its genuine later compositional continuation or a later thematically related episode. In condition U (unrelated context), it is followed by a length-, style- and intensity-matched but thematically unrelated episode. In condition F (familiarization), the target is repeated without the hypothesized informative context. Participants hear the target again after the condition-specific interval. Intervening silence, playback equipment, instruction length and response time should be standardized. A fourth full-work condition can be used to test whether excerpting destroys the effect the experiment intends to examine.
Sampling and selection. The first stage should recruit a small, purposive validation panel of pianists and music theorists to approve excerpt boundaries and check the theoretical classifications independently. A separate pilot could recruit approximately thirty adult listeners, balanced as far as feasible between trained and non-specialist participants, to establish whether response questions are intelligible and whether the selected contexts produce a measurable range of judgments. Thirty is a pragmatic piloting target, not a powered confirmatory sample. A subsequent confirmatory sample size must be calculated from the variance and effect-size uncertainty observed in piloting, using prospective simulation of the hierarchical model. Because musical examples are nested within composers, a single passage per composer would make an inference about composer-specific effects illegitimate even with a large participant sample.
Baseline and post-context questions. For each passage, participants rate perceived settlement versus openness, independence versus dependence, and tension versus release on anchored seven-point scales, marking ‘cannot tell’ where appropriate. They then provide a two- or three-sentence interpretation in their own terms and indicate whether a theme seems linked to material heard earlier. After the second target presentation, the same scales and explanation are repeated, with an additional item asking what musical feature, if any, prompted a changed impression. A distinct liking measure and a recognition question are collected separately. The categories are deliberately provisional: pilot comprehension checks may show that some are unusable and require the preregistration to be revised before confirmatory data collection.
Coding. Two independent coders, blind to condition and composer, classify each participant’s paired explanations as: 0, unchanged construal; 1, increased familiarity or liking only; 2, recognition of recurrence without expressive revision; 3, revised formal-function claim only; or 4, context-dependent revision of an earlier expressive construal. A rating of 4 requires the explanation to refer to a difference in earlier interpretation and to identify a feature plausibly supplied by the intervening material. Codable responses must be preserved verbatim for audit subject to informed consent. Disagreements are adjudicated under a fixed rubric, with pre-adjudication agreement reported. A merely larger numerical rating in the second encounter does not automatically qualify as RSR.
Primary estimand. For a prespecified target passage j and participant i, define Yij as 1 when a response meets the criterion for category 4 and 0 otherwise. The principal comparison is the difference in the probability of Yij between related and unrelated contexts, controlling for repetition. A hierarchical logistic model with participant and stimulus intercepts can estimate this difference; the composer-by-condition interaction is secondary and cannot support composer-wide generalization unless the study samples multiple works per composer. Treating every listener observation as an independent replication of the musical passage would produce pseudoreplication. Model specifications, planned exclusions, contrasts and multiplicity adjustments must be frozen before examining confirmatory outcomes.
Bias and demand mitigation. Participants should be told that the study concerns changes and stability in musical impressions, not that Medtner is expected to create superior or deeper meaning. The names of composers should be concealed during primary listening where feasible. Passage selection should include apparently favorable and unfavorable exemplars established by independent analysts. Investigators must document which contexts are substantially different in loudness, key, orchestration, register and timing; such differences may create superficial rating changes. Performance versions must be fixed and archived, with the historical editions identified. Rachmaninoff’s 1913 and 1931 versions must not be interchanged under one stimulus identifier.
Decision rule. A statistically significant difference by itself is insufficient if free-text coding shows only recognition or liking. Evidence for the construct requires both a related-context advantage over controls and substantive interpretive explanations. Evidence for Medtner’s *comparative* distinctiveness would additionally require a composer effect robust to passage selection and expertise. If effects disappear when an unrelated but emotionally similar context is substituted, or if Brahms and Rachmaninoff equal or exceed the Medtner passages, the original claim of Medtnerian exceptionalism must be narrowed or rejected. No pilot, ethics review, recruitment, preregistration or analysis has been conducted; the protocol remains a pre-empirical research instrument.
Reproducibility package and ethical boundary
Before data collection the working appendix should contain the full stimuli list, score edition and bar locator, source recording and license, excerpt timestamps, original excerpts’ structural functions, target-to-context matching table, participant instructions, response instrument, coder training examples, pilot amendment log, analytic script and an anonymized data dictionary. Ethical review is required where the study’s institutional context and methods call for it. Consent documentation should describe recording use and any quotation of listener responses. The research report must separate planned, exploratory and confirmatory tests. None of those materials may be fabricated retroactively to convert a theoretical argument into an empirical result.
The manuscript can meet a strong music-theoretical standard even without conducting a study, provided it refrains from claiming actual listening effects and offers an analytically sufficient demonstration of the compositional relationships. An experimental programme would be necessary for the stronger causal claim about what listeners reliably experience. The chapter should choose its claim and evidentiary burden explicitly rather than borrow the prestige of psychological research without the relevant work.
11Objections and limits of the present chapter
The strongest objection is priority. Schmalfeldt already demonstrated formal becoming, Gheorghieva explicitly described the organization of musical time as remembrance, and Rizzi addressed memory and narrative within the very corpus under discussion. The response cannot be that the present chapter uses more philosophical vocabulary. Its viable remainder is the restrictive difference between recognizing a relationship, revising formal function, and revising the expressive status of a prior event. Even this difference may overlap with existing phenomenological, cognitive, or narratological literature. Accordingly, the chapter claims a sharpened research problem and analytic synthesis, not secure conceptual first discovery.
A second objection concerns subjectivity. The same passage may sound consolatory to one listener and ominous to another. RSR therefore cannot be demonstrated by an analyst stipulating one correct affective meaning. The proposed outcome is a within-listener change attributable to specific later context, not universal agreement about what a theme “means.” Meaning remains plural, but claims about contextual influence can still be tested.
A third objection is the composer comparison. There is no representative Rachmaninoff score analysis here sufficient to justify an absolute judgment of difference. The original essay often relied on impressionistic antitheses that conflated accessibility and structural simplicity. The revision rejects those oppositions and requires an adversarial comparator. Until score locations and listening evidence are produced, the Medtner–Rachmaninoff distinction is a hypothesis with a genuine possibility of failure.
A fourth objection concerns sources. The construction of Op. 38 is described primarily through Shin’s dissertation, with support from the 1922 edition and public catalogue entries. Her research is unusually rich, but this chapter is not a new transcription of autographs or a new genetic study. A doctoral submission would require checking the reported measure locations and variants against the original score and critical editions, examining Rizzi’s and Shevchenko’s complete chapters, and reconciling competing Russian and English terminology. The evidence ledger below records that unfinished work openly.
12Conclusion: the value and limit of a second hearing
Medtner’s distinctive achievement cannot be defended by calling Rachmaninoff emotionally immediate and Medtner intellectually deep. Such labels underestimate both composers and mistake the critic’s experience for a comparative demonstration. Nor does the history of scholarly work permit the assertion that Medtner’s music is the newly discovered embodiment of memory. Musical time, thematic recollection, and retrospective formal reinterpretation are established fields of analysis.
What remains worth investigating is more exact. In the published architecture of Forgotten Melodies I, Medtner repeatedly places familiar thematic identities under new structural conditions. The modified second exposition does not simply consolidate what the first supplied. The recapitulation introduces a theme not previously heard. The closing movement restores the opening reminiscence idea after an intervening sequence of works, under altered harmonic and accompanimental conditions. These choices create documented opportunities for listeners to revisit an earlier construal rather than simply register the fact of recurrence.
The stronger claim—that these devices reliably change listeners’ interpretations and do so more than comparable techniques in Rachmaninoff—remains unproven. It should not be treated as established until both score analysis and listener evidence justify it. The chapter’s contribution is to isolate that question, define the evidence it requires, and show why it is not exhausted by existing accounts of memory or formal cyclicism.
If the inquiry succeeds, Medtner’s significance will lie partly in the management of interpretive time: how a composition can alter the status of something heard earlier through what it enables us to understand later. If it fails, his music will still offer an important instance of an experience more widely shared across the Romantic repertoire. Either outcome would be preferable to a claim of genius purchased at the expense of historical accuracy.
References and critical source record
Almén, Byron. 2008. A Theory of Musical Narrative. Bloomington: Indiana University Press. https://doi.org/10.2307/j.ctt2005szf.
Beller-McKenna, Daniel. 2021. “Imagination and Memory: Inter-movement Thematic Recall in Beethoven and Brahms.” Nineteenth-Century Music Review 18, no. 2: 283–308. https://doi.org/10.1017/S1479409820000294.
Bitzan, Wendelin. 2018. The Sonata as an Ageless Principle: Nikolai Medtner’s Early Piano Sonatas—Analytic Studies on Their Genesis, Style, and Compositional Technique. PhD diss., University of Music and Performing Arts Vienna. Open-access revision 2019. https://wendelinbitzan.de/writings/dissertation/.
British Library. Edna Iles Medtner Collection, MS Mus. 1748; correspondence MS Mus. 1748/2/1/1. Archives and Manuscripts Catalogue. https://searcharchives.bl.uk/catalog/032-002024141.
Carlson, Robert Brooks. 2021. “Rachmaninoff’s Second Piano Sonata, Op. 36: Large Scale Narrative Consequences of Revision.” James Madison Undergraduate Research Journal 8 (1): 53–62. https://commons.lib.jmu.edu/jmurj/vol8/iss1/6/.
Domico, Patrick H. 2025. Medtner the Symbolist. PhD diss., Indiana University. https://www.medtner.org.uk/publications.html.
Falterman, David. 2019. Two-Dimensional Sonata Form as Methodology: Understanding Sonata-Variation Hybrids through a Two-Dimensional Lens. MA thesis, University of North Texas. https://digital.library.unt.edu/ark:/67531/metadc1505161/.
Ferrer, Alexias L. 2025. A Case for the Original Setting of Rachmaninoff’s Piano Sonata No. 2, Op. 36. DMA diss., Louisiana State University. https://doi.org/10.31390/gradschool_dissertations.6684.
Gheorghieva, Maria. 2020. “Организация музыкального времени в Сонате-воспоминании (ор. 38) Н. Метнера” [Organisation of Musical Time in Sonata-Reminiscenza (Op. 38) by N. Medtner]. Studiul artelor şi culturologie: istorie, teorie, practică, no. 1 (36): 87–92. https://ibn.idsi.md/sites/default/files/imag_file/87-92_13.pdf.
Huron, David. 2006. Sweet Anticipation: Music and the Psychology of Expectation. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
Lasarenko, Kim Andrei. 1988. A Style Change in Rachmaninoff’s Piano Music as Seen in the Second Piano Sonata in B-flat Minor, Opus 36 (1913 and 1931 Versions). DMA doctoral document, Ohio State University. https://etd.ohiolink.edu/acprod/odb_etd/ws/send_file/send?accession=osu1389185090&disposition=inline.
Library of Congress, Music Division. Nikolay Karlovich Medtner Papers, ML31.M43. Finding aid. https://findingaids.loc.gov/repositories/15/resources/1285.
Margulis, Elizabeth Hellmuth. 2018. “Repetition.” In The Oxford Handbook of Critical Concepts in Music Theory. Oxford: Oxford University Press. https://doi.org/10.1093/oxfordhb/9780190454746.013.22.
Markson, Oliver H. 2017. A Study of Nikolai Medtner’s Compositional Technique: Form and Narrative in Tales. DMA diss., City University of New York Graduate Center. https://academicworks.cuny.edu/gc_etds/1853/.
Medtner, Nikolai. 1922. Vergessene Weisen, I. Zyklus, Op. 38. Leipzig: Jules Heinrich Zimmermann. Plate Z. 11052–059. Digitized first edition, Sibley Music Library, Eastman School of Music. https://urresearch.rochester.edu/institutionalPublicationPublicView.action?institutionalItemId=19129.
Medtner, Nikolai. 1951. The Muse and the Fashion: Being a Defence of the Foundations of the Art of Music. Translated by Alfred J. Swan. Haverford, PA: Haverford College Bookstore.
Medtner Reference Website. n.d. “Forgotten Melodies, First Cycle, Op. 38.” Includes composition chronology, early programme, recordings, and a comparison of the 1922 and 1959 editions. Accessed November 15, 2026. https://www.medtner.org.uk/op38.html.
Meyer, Leonard B. 1956. Emotion and Meaning in Music. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Miao, Chang. 2026. The Russian Soul in Piano Sonatas: Rachmaninoff in Dialogue with Scriabin and Medtner. Thesis or dissertation, University of Alabama. https://ir.ua.edu/items/8b3a6570-88a9-4f52-88db-aaa65ff1a39a.
Miranda, Christopher John. 2016. Nikolai Medtner: Performing Imagination in His Sonata Reminiscenza, Op. 38 No. 1. Doctor of Music dissertation, Indiana University. https://hdl.handle.net/2022/20855.
Predvechnova, E. O. 2021. “Семантический анализ-интерпретация на примере «Сонаты-воспоминания» a-moll, ор. 38, № 1 Н. К. Метнера” [Semantic Analysis-Interpretation of Medtner’s Sonata-Reminiscenza in A Minor, Op. 38, No. 1]. Вестник музыкальной науки [Journal of Musical Science] 9, no. 3: 43–51. https://doi.org/10.24412/2308-1031-2021-3-43-51. https://vestnik.nsglinka.ru/uploads/pdf/2021-T9-3/043-051.pdf.
Rachmaninoff, Sergei. 1913 [first issued 1914]. Piano Sonata No. 2 in B-flat Minor, Op. 36. Moscow: A. Gutheil. First-edition facsimile, IMSLP no. 509056. https://imslp.org/wiki/Piano_Sonata_No.2%2C_Op.36_%28Rachmaninoff%2C_Sergei%29.
Rachmaninoff, Sergei. 1931. Piano Sonata No. 2 in B-flat Minor, Op. 36, revised version. Paris: A. Gutheil. First-edition facsimile, IMSLP no. 40924. https://imslp.org/wiki/Piano_Sonata_No.2%2C_Op.36_%28Rachmaninoff%2C_Sergei%29.
Rahmer, Dominik, ed. 2018. Critical commentary to Sergei Rachmaninoff, Piano Sonata No. 2, Op. 36, original and revised versions. Munich: G. Henle Verlag, HN 1256, pp. 75–77. https://www.henle.de/media/fa/8b/38/1697725761/1256-1697725761-sync.pdf.
Rizzi, Nicolò. 2021. “Memory and Oblivion: Narrative Traces in Medtner’s Forgotten Motives.” In Nikolai Medtner: Music, Aesthetics, and Contexts, edited by Wendelin Bitzan and Christoph Flamm, 49–94. https://doi.org/10.5771/9783487424521-49.
Schubert, Franz. 1822. Fantasie in C Major, D. 760, Op. 15 (“Wanderer Fantasy”). First published Vienna: Cappi & Diabelli, 1823. Score witnesses catalogued at https://imslp.org/wiki/Wanderer_Fantasy_D.760_%28Schubert%2C_Franz%29.
Schmalfeldt, Janet. 2011. In the Process of Becoming: Analytical and Philosophical Perspectives on Form in Early Nineteenth-Century Music. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Shevchenko, Tatyana. 2021. “Medtner’s Piano Sonatas as a Subject of Performative Interpretation: Case Study: Sonata-Reminiscenza, Op. 38 No. 1.” In Nikolai Medtner: Music, Aesthetics, and Contexts, edited by Wendelin Bitzan and Christoph Flamm, 39–48. https://doi.org/10.5771/9783487424521-39.
Shin, Haeshin. 2018. Nikolai Medtner’s Forgotten Melodies, Op. 38: Sources, Analysis, and Interpretation. DMA diss., Boston University. https://hdl.handle.net/2144/30197.
Tarasova, Evgeniya B. 2023. Н. К. Метнер. Фортепианный цикл «Забытые мотивы». Тетрадь I (ор. 38). Опыт работы в классе специального фортепиано [N. K. Medtner: Forgotten Melodies, Book I (Op. 38): Experience in the Advanced Piano Class]. Moscow: Russian Gnessin Academy of Music Publishing House, 88 pp. Institutional catalogue: https://gnesin-academy.ru/sveden/struct/nauchno-izdatelskij-centr/.
Vande Moortele, Steven. 2009. Two-Dimensional Sonata Form: Form and Cycle in Single-Movement Instrumental Works by Liszt, Strauss, Schoenberg and Zemlinsky. Leuven: Leuven University Press. https://doi.org/10.2307/j.ctt9qf14r.
Zaitseva, Ekaterina. 2017. The Culmination of the Russian Romantic Piano School as Represented by Early and Late Works of Rachmaninoff, Scriabin, and Medtner. DMA diss., University of Maryland. https://api.drum.lib.umd.edu/server/api/core/bitstreams/b6a8617f-c537-4078-a2d5-de457b3b1213/content.
Editorial note: Russian-language titles are accompanied by descriptive English translations in brackets. Complete title-page and pagination collation of all editions, particularly the collected editions, remains pending; this list is a verified working bibliography, not a claim to exhaustive bibliography.